Showing posts with label terrorism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label terrorism. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 17, 2007

The "War On Terror": Rickety And Useless

On Monday, British international development secretary Hillary Benn [CORRECTION: see below] gave a speech in New York in which he made a convincing argument against the phrase "war on terror":

In the UK, we do not use the phrase "war on terror" because we can't win by military means alone, and because this isn't us against one organised enemy with a clear identity and a coherent set of objectives.

It is the vast majority of the people in the world - of all nationalities and faiths - against a small number of loose, shifting and disparate groups who have relatively little in common apart from their identification with others who share their distorted view of the world and their idea of being part of something bigger.

What these groups want is to force their individual and narrow values on others, without dialogue, without debate, through violence. And by letting them feel part of something bigger, we give them strength.


Benn is right: The war on terror formulation serves the PR purposes of a thousand different militant groups and is a strategic blunder of epic proportions. Reading Benn's comments, I was reminded of what happened when I called in to an awful right-wing talk show somewhere in central New Jersey. The guest was promoting some DVD and book about the global jihadist conspiracy and the danger it posed to us civilized Westerners. The phrase "Islamofascism" came up, and I couldn't help myself. I dialed the number, told the producer what I wanted to talk about, and waited. I got on relatively quickly, and the conversation went something like this:

HOST: "Jesse, welcome to the show."

ME: "Thanks. I just wanted to disagree with your use of the term 'Islamofascism.' I feel like it's a mistake to lump all these groups together. When you look at Al Qaeda, Hamas, Hezbollah -- they all have different goals and were formed for different reasons. Many of them aren't really about fundamentalist Islam, and it makes things more difficult when we sweep them all into the same category."

HOST: "Whoa. Jesse, Jesse. You do realize they are trying to kill you, right?"

That was it. Since I disagreed with the manner in which terrorism was being debated, I clearly didn't understand that there existed, somewhere, people who wanted to kill me. I've seen this happen a thousand times on a thousand different shows -- anyone who doesn't toe the absolutist line is told they are either naive or a traitor. If you don't admit that we are in a battle for our very existence, that our enemy is absolutely evil and we are almost absolutely good, and that the enemy hates us because of our way of life (an intentionally loose term that can be filled in on the fly -- they hate us because we vote, they hate us because we let our women wear bikinis), then you are part of the problem.

The war on terror is an intellectual framework that, thanks to its broadness, answers several tough questions in advance: Who are we fighting? Whomever terrorizes us. Whose fault is terrorism? Theirs, obviously; we're the ones fighting terrorism. When have we won? When there are no longer groups committing terrorist acts. It's unfortunate that these questions were neutered so shortly after 9/11. It would be nice to, you know, debate them.

It would also help us focus our efforts. It's tactically insane to treat Al Qaeda, Hezbollah, Hamas, and the Iranian government as parts of the same undifferentiated mass. This lack of precision, this inability to comprehend nuance, comes from the war on terror model, which postulates that the cause of terrorism is evil itself. Evil, of course, isn't reductive and can't be bargained with, so it's not worth sitting down with any of these groups.

The most tragic result of the war on terror's rickety facade has been Iraq. Imagine if, after 9/11, the administration had described the conflict in more accurate terms. Imagine if all of the cable news networks that ceaselessly flashed idiotic electrified logos touting THE WAR ON TERROR as the fall's hottest new product had instead had the temerity to question the formulation the American government presented its people. Would the Iraq war have happened if we were fighting something less vague than "terror" itself? If the proper people had questioned President Bush, had asked him, "How can you possibly link a nationalist, secular tyrant leader like Saddam Hussein to a radical pan-Islamist like Bin Laden?"? But it wasn't important enough. Terms like "Sunni" and "Shiite" and "pan-Islamist" weren't yet en vogue, because we weren't fighting anything that specific; we were fighting terror.

"Neoconservative" is used far too often, too loosely, and in too conspiratorial a manner, but the fact of the matter is that the neoconservatives -- Donald Rumsfeld, Dick Cheney, Richard Perle, and Paul Wolfowitz, just to name a few -- were and are largely responsible for the war on terror and its stark, epic imagery. The BBC ran an excellent critique of the neoconservatives' role in designing the war on terror in "The Power of Nightmares," a three-part documentary that aired a few years ago and which can be watched on Google Video. It's very effective at explaining the neoconservative infatuation with big, evil, Enemies to End All Enemies. For a while, the Soviets served this role, then no one, then, after 9/11, the Islamofascists. The people who have been most influential in leading us to war in Iraq see America's destiny as nothing less (or more complicated) than fighting evil, and have never let the nuances of reality interfere with this messianic vision.

It's 2007 and we are still unable to have a mature, intelligent discussion about terrorism. I hope an American politician or two will take a cue from Hillary Benn and start to deconstruct the war on terror, which has gotten us nowhere.

(Almost forgot: I would be remiss if I failed to mention James Fallows's excellent Atlantic piece from last fall, "Declaring Victory," which expertly explains what's wrong with the U.S. approach to fighting terrorism.)

[CORRECTION: I originally had the international development secretary's last name as Bunn, not Benn, throughout the post.]

Thursday, April 12, 2007

Richard Perle Still Doesn't Get It

In Foreign Policy's latest Seven Questions, the magazine interviews neoconservative mastermind Richard Perle. Perle, of course, takes what is now a very common position amongst those who pushed hardest for war -- good war, bad execution. Neither a convincing opinion nor a surprising one. Where his logic really starts to eat itself is in his contention that, if Iraq has replaced Afghanistan as a terror magnet, this is a good thing:

FP: Francis Fukuyama wrote in the New York Times last year that "Iraq has now replaced Afghanistan as a magnet, a training ground and an operational base for jihadist terrorists." Do you agree?

RP: I'm not sure whether that's true or not, but it's an improvement if it is. Let me explain: Afghanistan was certainly a magnet, and jihadists traveled there from wherever they originated. They were welcomed there, they were trained there, and they worked under very favorable circumstances, with lines of communication and the ability to plan and organize. Now, the jihadists who have flocked to Iraq are themselves in constant danger, large numbers of them are killed, and they're certainly not in a position to plan operations against American territory. So if you ask me whether we are safer with jihadists converging on Baghdad or jihadists converging on camps in Afghanistan and planning events like 9/11, there's no doubt that we're a lot safer because they're converging on Baghdad.

Now, it's important to remember that he's responding to a hypothetical, and one he isn't sure he agrees with. Nonetheless, the content of his answer is very telling and reflects some of the biggest misconceptions about Iraq, Afghanistan, and the war on terror. Since Perle's reasoning is faulty on almost every level, I'll just focus on the three facts that most undermine it.

1) The Iraq war made -- and is making -- more terrorists.
Perle seems to be implying that there is a set number of terrorists. So, since we've been able to divert some of them from Afghanistan, a welcoming environment, to Iraq, where much of the population dislikes foreign fighters, we're winning. Things don't work this way. The Iraq war, as the U.S. government's own intelligence reports have shown, has radicalized much of the Muslim world, and has drawn in many young men who would otherwise have had little interest in jihadism. So it's not a choice, as Perle is arguing, between having terrorists in Iraq or having terrorists in Afghanistan. We have both, and thanks to the war jihadism is spreading far faster than it would have otherwise.

2) Afghanistan does provide a more welcoming operational environment for Al Qaeda, but we're losing there as well. Things have gotten so bad in Afghanistan and Waziristan, Pakistan's lawless northwest frontier, that even the mainstream media have picked up on it. In recent months, both Newsweek and Time have run stories about the failure of the U.S. and NATO to make permanent progress against Al Qaeda and the Taliban there. Al Qaeda's command hierarchy was largely smashed after the Taliban was ousted, but, now that the organization is starting to rebuild with little interference from the West, it's likely that the next large-scale attack will be hatched in Afghanistan or Waziristan. Of course, one of the reasons we've been unable to lock things down on this front (apart from the region's massive, treacherous geography, our inability to understand the culture there, and the difficulty in rooting out an enemy that can bleed into local populations) is -- you guessed it -- that we're devoting far more resources to Iraq. And, as everybody now knows, Iraq had nothing to do with Al Qaeda.

3) There aren't that many foreign jihadists in Iraq. For Bush, Perle, and the others who have framed this war as part of an existential struggle against Terror or Islamofascism (one of the most ill-conceived buzzwords in recent memory, and worth its own post), nothing is more important than pushing the idea that the carnage in Iraq is the result of meddlesome foreign influences and wave after wave of Al Qaeda members sweeping in to set up shop and launch a series of massive, devastating attacks against the U.S. If, instead, it's mostly just Iraqis killing Iraqis and Iraqis killing U.S. troops and vice-versa, then a) this really can't be logically tied to the war on terror, since none of the parties involved attacked us prior to March 2003, and b) there's a strong argument to be made that the war was unwinnable, that the forces unleashed by the post-Saddam power vacuum were too powerful to be contained by a U.S. effort of a politically or economically feasible scale. So it's unfortunate for Bush and Perle's rhetoric that such a small fraction of Iraq's violence comes from outside Iraq. The Brookings Institution estimates (PDF, see page 22) that as of last November there were a grand total of between 800 and 2,000 foreign fighters in Iraq -- an almost negligible fraction of the insurgency. The majority of the fighting in Iraq is either between Iraqis or between Iraqis and U.S. troops. Foreign fighters simply don't have the support of most native Iraqis, would be hard-pressed to establish any kind of permanent presence in the country, and have not stormed Iraq's borders on a scale that would support Perle's reasoning. It's a very convenient fiction, however.

So why is Perle making these claims? Did he not do his homework, or is he being disingenuous and trying like so many other pro-war types to salvage whatever he can from a huge, smoking pile of rubble? I'm really not sure. But his comments are yet another reminder that the people at the helm in the post-9/11 world either don't understand the way terrorism works, or don't care enough to learn.